11 Comments
User's avatar
Sido Surkis's avatar

Peter - I love reading these essays of yours, I appreciate them immensely! Well written and well researched, always with a dash oh your wonderful warmth and humor! Abrazos!

Expand full comment
Jewish Grandmother's avatar

I have to agree with Sido, who expressed my sentiments exactly. Bravo, Peter. Keep them coming!

Expand full comment
Laurie Gough's avatar

I agree with you, Peter. And what about the glut of pseudo-scientific therapies like homeopathy, Reiki, “energy medicine”, and acupuncture, all of which have the same rate of “healing” as a placebo? Here’s an interesting article: https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/acupuncture-doesnt-work/

Expand full comment
Paula Dunning's avatar

Nice...as always!

Expand full comment
Lee Gould's avatar

Fascinating… thanks Peter…

Expand full comment
HuFin's avatar

Another terrific commentary, Peter. And those illustrations by Sadie are wonderful. She has a great career ahead of her. Keep them coming. And now I can remove those leeches, finally. Thank God I didn't agree to the lobotomy. Hugh

Expand full comment
hp's avatar

Hi Peter,

You might enjoy the book "Ending Medical Reversal" by Cifu and Prasad. I didn't know there was an official term for flip flops until I came across the book. A PubMed/Google search for medical reversal is enlightening.

You also might find the Substack Sensible Medicine interesting https://sensiblemed.substack.com/.

As for your previous posting, this recently came into my email inbox: the debate continues https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/dairy-fat-forever-flirting-pure-diet-nonsense-david-l-katz-md-mph/

Expand full comment
Ken Urquhart's avatar

Hello Peter - I enjoyed reading your article. I just joined your Substack, and this is the first of your articles that I've read. I was steered here by a mutual friend of ours, Danny Kornhauser. I look forward to reading more of your articles. Keep up the good writing, Ken Urquhart.

Expand full comment
Adam H.'s avatar

Interesting and absorbing! Keep it coming Dr. Newman!!

Expand full comment
Manuela Thiess Garcia's avatar

It seems I have finally been able to sign in, so I will leave a comment without worrying that it will be deleted when I am through.

Your essays about your years of practicing medicine are not only well and amusingly written, Peter, but they are informative. As with this one, I have yet to read one and not learn something.

Gracias. I appreciate being on the mailing list.

Expand full comment
David Blatt's avatar

Hey Peter. I had a sports medicine doctor I really liked for ulnar neuropathy I have in both my elbows. He would discuss different options and how he viewed the possible outcome for those options. I really liked this approach as he wasn't giving me the "miracle cure" just his best opinion on how to move forward

Expand full comment